patching...
Update: Did you know that there is a Peachtree Corners Facebook page? Click HERE and check it out. »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Should Violent Games Be Reviewed and More Closely Regulated?

In the wake of the shootings in Connecticut, many are calling for stricter gun control and smaller ammunition magazines, but the National Rifle Association’s Wayne LaPierre claims it isn’t all about the guns. He's asking us to look to video games.

 

Is it possible that desensitization due to over-exposure to violence can be a factor in mass murders such as the one perpetrated in Connecticut? That’s one possible theory.

But Rowell Huesmann and Eric Dubow of the Aggression Research Program at the Institute for Social Research at the University of Michigan feel it is more than that — games may provide a script that makes these murderers more confident in their actions. And while most teens reject the “script” as flat-out wrong or fictional, there are those who are psychologically damaged who do not reject this common script.  

“We must strive to find ways, without trampling on the right of free artistic expression, to reduce youth exposure to violence in life and in the mass media," Huesmann and Dubow said in a press release Dec. 17. "Violence is a contagious disease, particularly for youth. The more they are exposed to it, the more likely they are to catch it.”  

Does it require legislation?

According to politico.com, Senate Commerce Committee Chairman Jay Rockefeller has already introduced a bill that would have the National Academy of Sciences examine possible links between violent video games and media, and violent acts by children.

“Recent court decisions demonstrate that some people still do not get it,” Rockefeller said in a statement. “They believe that violent video games are no more dangerous to young minds than classic literature or Saturday morning cartoons. Parents, pediatricians and psychologists know better. These court decisions show we need to do more and explore ways Congress can lay additional groundwork on this issue. This report will be a critical resource in this process. I call on my colleagues to join me in passing this important legislation quickly.”

Gamers say, "NO!"

But the New York Daily News reports gamers are calling for a ban on guns as a solution, not games. Citing a statement from Jim Welling, the manager of Video Games New York, “it's dumb blaming everything on video games. I don't see any of our customers going out and trying to kill someone just because of a video game.” 

We do love our video games and it would seem that "gamers" truly enjoy virtual war, rather than dancing. Three of Amazon.com's lists of the four top-selling games this year include Halo 4, Call of Duty: Black Ops II and Assassin's Creed IIIJust Dance 4 came in at number two.  

What do you think? Tighter controls on violent games or should it be the responsibility of parents to monitor the games their children are playing? Is this a multifaceted problem that is going to take more than a quick congressional fix on either guns and/or games?

Related Topics: Congressional Ban, Video Games, Violence, and question of the day

jamie jones

10:00 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012

As a mom, I feel that violent video games are part of the problem. We are teaching our children that violence is fun and should be enjoyed. My Grandfather served in WW2 and he never recovered from the horrors he had to endure. War is not fun nor should we glorify it to be a walk in the park.

Reply

Tammy Osier

10:00 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012

They already have ratings. the problem is the parent that buys it for his /her child and gives them no boundaries. It is a parenting problem, not a game problem. Although, I've seen some and would never let my child play them.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jason Caldwell

8:29 am on Friday, December 28, 2012

I agree Tammy, I am a gamer as are my children but they do not play Mature rated games. Parents need to be more involved in their children's lives and not let games give them "time off" from parenting. There are people who are psychologically damaged for one reason or another, blaming games, guns or knives is overreaction and not helpful. It is a guilty consciousness that is trying to find a thing, or person to blame. Banning something will not stop it from happening again unfortunately.

Nate

10:00 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012

I used to play one of the war games until my family asked me to stop because it was making me more aggressive. It was beccoming addictive and would leave me wound up and aggitated. Not that it does to everyone, but it can have that effect. I worry what it might do to our children. I have since thrown the game away. I thank my family for bringing this to my attention before it was too late.

Reply

Patrick T. Malone

10:24 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012

Shouldn't parents be the ones reviewing and regulating video games at least for those under 18?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Karsten Torch

3:42 pm on Friday, December 28, 2012

Should be, but that would require us to expect people to be parents.

Plus, how would the government be able to be involved if people actually parented?

George Wilson

10:56 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012

In its bizarre and tone deaf response last week to the shootings in Newtown, Conn., the National Rifle Association heaped blame on “vicious, violent video games” for corrupting young Americans and called them the “filthiest form of pornography.” As it turns out, many of those very games have marketing relationships with the makers of firearms and ammunition, which are also big financial supporters of the N.R.A., through deals that appear to be designed to increase sales of their deadly wares.This is nothing more than a diversion put forth by the NRA.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Crystal Huskey

11:08 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012

There isn't just one thing to blame for our violent culture. We glorify violence in various forms, from simple spy movies to films like Kill Bill, down to the worst of the horror movies that would shake up anyone's core. Yes, these damage people. Garbage in, garbage out. That doesn't mean it's to blame for mass shootings, but it doesn't help.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Gail Moore

12:18 pm on Thursday, December 27, 2012

I understand that Lanza didn't play the violent video games - but was much more of a sci-fi gamer, so I'm not sure that it plays much into this. I was very interested in the thought, though, that watching violence - either on the news or through movies/games - can help those who can't make a distinction between real/fiction or evaluate consequences to find a "script" or scenario that seems doable to them.

Reply

Tammy Osier

8:29 pm on Thursday, December 27, 2012

I heard that too Gail. But too much of anything is too much. I had a kid at a school where I worked, that had a supposedly 'good' habit. He read books. Problem is, he did no work, was violent with those who tried to take them away to get his attention. At some point, you had to wonder if he could tell reality from what he was reading. So, he may not even had read something violent, but because he was given no boundaries and balance in his life, he became obsessed to the point of becoming violent with others. Strange how that works. But if this (conn.) kid had autism, you can see where the mom felt that he would always need someone to take care of him, therefore, let him do what he wanted. Bad all the way around.
I allowed my son to play games (some were pretty violent), but I told him that if I saw any personality or behavioral changes, they would go promptly in the trash. I didn't care how much he paid for them. I actually did throw some cd's in the trash when he was 16 (for getting into trouble). He told me that for my information, some of those cd's belonged to his friends. I said, "Well, that'll teach them to loan anything to you knowing what a wacko mother you have" LOL. It's a true story that we laugh about today (He's 27 now).

Reply

Denna Millard

7:37 am on Friday, December 28, 2012

All video needs to be approved by some kind of governmental rule before placing for sale. There are violent videos that all ages are watching that are giving ideas for crime. Violent gangs are growing by leaps and bounds. This is MAJOR PROBLEM THAT NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED IMMEDIATELY!!! Parents need to take action to take AWAY VIOLENT VIDEOS FROM ALL CHILDREN NOW!!!. Get your children some kind of emotional help to de-program them from violent tendencies.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Karsten Torch

3:44 pm on Friday, December 28, 2012

I'm hoping this post is facetious...

Tom Laverick

8:52 am on Friday, December 28, 2012

There are ratings on games for a reason. Games and violent tv are only partially to blame for the problem in society today. The biggest problem is our lack of parenting and trying to be our kids friends and not a parent. We all want our kids to have better lives than what we had, but we are doing it at the risk of what we are seeing today. We failed them and now they are failing us. When they did something wrong we laughed and said oh it's just kids being kids, we only taught them partially right from wrong and when they did something serious they get put in the corner for time out.... WTH do you expect kids to think when they get older, they do not realize this simple fact: "There are real consequences for they're actions" they think Oh Boy i'm going to get put into the corner again... Big deal I could be put in a corner all day and not think twice about it! We removed the death penalty and the murder rate climbs, go figure. I can now kill someone and not worry about them taking my life. I get to go live somewhere warm, get 3 meals a day, get access to one of the greatest health care systems in the world and get a free college education. And you still want to play the "ITS NOT MY FAULT" game or the Government needs to do something... Seriously get your head out of the sand. we created this mess and now we have to live with it.

IT IS NOT THE GOVERNMENTS RESPONSIBILITY TO RAISE OUR KIDS. IT"S OURS

Reply

Michael Robinson

9:08 am on Friday, December 28, 2012

Video games are the new records praising Satan when played backwards. Same hysterical nonsense, different media.

Reply

Marne M

9:17 am on Friday, December 28, 2012

Video games are rated. It's my job as a parent to decide what I feel is appropriate for my children, and to monitor their habits and behavior. I do not need the government telling me (any more than they already do) what I may and may not teach my children. Will they also tell me what my children may and may not read? Perhaps violent books are the problem -- there was a lot of violence in Harry Potter and the Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (war and slaughter, oh my -- we should ban them)! My kids enjoy National Geographic specials about violent creatures like dinosaurs and sea creatures. Are they going to grow into damaged teenagers and adults because I allow them to play "Velociraptor Attack" in the living room?

I'm perfectly capable of turning off the television and the computer all by myself, without government interference.

Reply

Karsten Torch

3:47 pm on Friday, December 28, 2012

Yeah, it's the video games. Of course it is. Has anybody actually watched the news lately? Much worse than any video game I've ever seen.

Just another way for people to not take responsibility for themselves or theirs.

Reply

Karsten Torch

3:49 pm on Friday, December 28, 2012

Truth is, government has no business in this. It's up to me to watch my kid(s) and decide what they will and won't watch. And it's my job to be a parent, not my kids' friend. Just sayin...

Reply

Tammy Osier

4:36 pm on Friday, December 28, 2012

Bottm line from all who posted - parental responsibility.

Reply

Amy Jellicoe

5:15 pm on Friday, December 28, 2012

I had to do an argumentative paper on this very topic. I would like to think I am uniquely qualified to speak on this. The research shows that kids were equally aggressive after watching 'wrassling' or violent movies and TV shows. The aggression wasn't enough to cause mass murders, and girls were less aggressive than boys. Like you said Tammy, it all comes down to parental Supervision.

Reply

Tammy Osier

5:48 pm on Friday, December 28, 2012

Amy, I'm contemplating going back to school and my papers will be on the subject of social services and abnormal psychology so my mindset is towards finding stuff like this. It's interesting that the aggression didn't last in the testers, but for some reason, builds up in some. That would be an interesting study, to find out why. Try some of these subjects for study. Do some research on "temperaments" in childhood and personalities (also, personality disorders vs psychosis). Do some research on the differences and correlations to environment vs heredity. There, you'll find that the same two people can play the same game the same amount of time etc... and react differently. You'll find a lot of good stuff. I'd be interested in the numbers when you have them. Good luck!
Also, I read something about being able to autopsy and study the brains of mass murders and those that commit thes e types of atrocities. I wonder what's different in their make-up that might help science look for similarities in potential at risk people? It's a thought, for sure.

Reply

bobby black

6:02 pm on Friday, December 28, 2012

No doubt the games cause some of the agressive behaviour but has anyone ever paid attention to the TV that they are watching? I believe that TV is the biggest problem.

Reply

Tammy Osier

6:40 pm on Friday, December 28, 2012

Bb- you have a point. I've been saying for years that the generation raised on television is a different breed. Think about it. Before tV, what did kids do? They played outside. They interacted with real people and had to solve real conflicts. Even when we did watch violent westerns with shooting and killing, and went to scary movies (I was raised in the 60's and even then they were bloody), we released the effects of our fears in play the next day. We worked it out, so to speak. Today, add tv, movies and violent video games where a kid sits for hours and has no outlet to process what they take in (without the proper amount of play), and wala! They internalize it, and it can come out in a myriad of manifestations. Couple that with lack of discipline and a permissive society and you have a different kid from yesteryear.

Reply

Karsten Torch

8:17 am on Saturday, December 29, 2012

So..let's assume that we all agree parenting needs to get better and more involved for most folks....

Still leaves us with the question of "Should the government be involved?" To which I answer emphatically "No!" Still not the government's job. Plus, if we want to properly mess something up, let the government get involved. That'll show us just how NOT to do something....

Reply

Leave a comment